Trunk Sale

Aside from some gross racial caricaturing the original Dumbo (1941) is an unusually hand-made cartoon. Here in 64 minutes is not just the elephant child’s tragedy at being separated from its mother, but the sweat and stink of a circus, and a squad of clowns who are dangerous and who really know their business. In the magnificent “Pink Elephants on Parade” sequence, the animators went after the pretensions of Fantasia, with strobing color and surrealism. It’s the rare instant of Disney being as funny as a Bugs Bunny cartoon.

Director Tim Burton’s new live action version is, by contrast, cluttered and starchy and not about to make risky jokes about drunken animals. In 1919, the trick rider Holt Farrier (Colin Farrell, appealing) comes back from WW1 missing an arm. He returns to the battered circus run by Max Medici (Danny DeVito). His late wife left behind their two kids: young Joe (Finley Hobbins) and Millie (Nico Parker, Thandie Newton’s daughter). Parker does her lines in a clipped, precocious Wednesday Addams diction—she’s a science geek with little interest in circuses. They are there to be kids in a family movie that doesn’t have a lot of interest in the kids’ characters.

The down and out circus is saved by the birth of an elephant with freakishly big ears who can fly. The wondrous beast attracts the attention of a tycoon (Michael Keaton) who owns a Coney Island-style park. He brings with him the French aerialist Collette (Eva Green), who is by a mile Dumbo’s most redeeming quality. Green excels at the New Vaudeville look, leggy, glittery costumes, with bobbed hair and a ceramic-hard mask of charm: the chosen face of a performer meant to be seen from 50 feet away. The soaring pachyderm does not intimidate her: “I know how to fly, ever since my childhood.” It was an inspiration to give Dumbo a partner, someone to calm the creature. A satisfying moment after a tumble from the heights into the net: the elephant and the lady bounce into a cozy position, like a couple greeting guests from a couch.

Disney’s Dumbo is a three-ring circus that needs ring mastering; Burton’s preference for atmosphere over lucid storytelling means that it’s hectic; the circus folk given a quick display and then the plot mislays them. Disney’s Dumbo isn’t Burton’s worst—that’s Dark Shadows—but it plays more like Spielberg doing kid-fodder with the help of Burton as production designer. The movie is a white elephant.

‘Dumbo’ is playing in wide release.

Western Swing

If there is a place that better blends agricultural heritage with a literate, urbane sensibility than Point Reyes Station and environs, then I haven’t found it.

First stop? Philip K. Dick’s former house, a kind of pilgrimage for me, as Dick’s one of my favorite writers. The science-fiction legend famously lived in town for a few years in the late 1950s and early 1960s. Typing away in his kitchen, he wrote numerous short stories and his novel, The Man in the High Castle, winner of the Hugo Award in 1963 and subject of a recent Amazon series. I stood in front of the house awhile. The “Face of God” that Phil claimed to see in his Pt. Reyes backyard was nowhere to be found—I checked—but the long-awaited pilgrimage to his iconic house was complete. I headed over to Ink.Paper.Plate for a chat with Sirima Sataman.

The Artist At Work

Sataman’s had a lot going on over the past couple of years. She’s had a show at the Bolinas Museum. And the Saltwater Oyster Depot in Inverness displays her prints, which brings more visitors to the multi-functional workspace, teaching space, retail outlet and community gathering space that is Ink.Paper.Plate.

Sataman’s story has many twists and turns. She studied printing, weaving, and sculpture in college, but a more “serious” career got its hooks in her after graduation and she spent years working an office job. “The universe kicked me out of my old career,” she says. Her son was fully grown by then and she was debt-free, so Sataman decided to roll the proverbial dice and become a full-time artist. She found the storefront that would become Ink.Paper.Plate and took up residence in Bolinas.

The largest pieces on the walls are all Sataman’s, but the workshop also displays prints by other artists and students. One wall features more than a dozen small posters for West Marin bands like The Haggards—all produced by local musicians who learned the craft from her.

If you’re not familiar, the old-time printmaking process is pretty cool. First, Sataman sketches an image on a thin piece of wood before carefully carving out the areas that won’t transfer ink to paper. Then she slathers the wood with black ink before subjecting wood and paper to extreme pressure to produce the image. Print runs can end suddenly when the wood plates shatter during the transfer. The paper, too, must be especially thick to survive the process.

Sataman had two plates on display at different stages. The first was a sketch of the Point Reyes Lighthouse with some carving already completed. Like the real lighthouse undergoing restoration and closed to the public, it’s a work in progress. The second was a well-used plate—the picture was of a local church— covered in dry ink. Although the plate looked worn, it still had some life in it for more prints. (Her art adorns the cover of the Pacific Sun this week.)

I left Sataman’s studio for some refreshment at the Old Western Saloon where the only customers on a Sunday afternoon are locals and motorcyclists Irishing up their coffee. The place smells of cigarette smoke, and the liquor bottles sport a thin layer of dust. Perfect. Enjoying a beer as you admire the photographs of Prince Charles’ 2005 visit hanging above the bar. Preserved in a glass case are his and Duchess Camilla’s pint glasses.

Rainy Day Ramblin’

The rain was coming down hard the next day and my car made the “smart” decision to take me from Petaluma to Pt. Reyes on the Petaluma-Marshall road. After 15 miles of impenetrable fog, wet asphalt, and one logging truck, I arrived at Highway 1 and the Marshall Store. I ordered a cup of clam chowder and six raw oysters. The oysters were cold, the chowder was boiling. I doused the soup with black pepper as I took in the iconic view of Tomales Bay. I considered my scalded gums and white knuckles, and got back on the road for the short hop to Pt. Reyes. The town has a number of “It’s the only town in West Marin with a . . . “ features. It’s the only town in West Marin with a pharmacy—West Marin Pharmacy. It’s also the only town in West Marin with auto-service stations (Chedas and Greenridge Gas and Auto) and it’s the only town in West Marin with a radio station, the great KWMR. It’s not the only place in West Marin where you can buy a gallon of gas, unless you want to drop nearly $6 for a gallon at Bo-Gas down the road (it’s for a good cause—affordable housing—but still).

Like most of West Marin County on a Monday, it’s pretty quiet in Pt. Reyes as the work week gets going. Locals know this is the day to go grocery shopping, after the tourist-intense weekend has ended. I went to the Palace Market for a Marin Kombucha, oak-aged and flavored with apple and juniper. It tasted just like slightly sweet tea and I loved the brown-glass bottle, something straight out of an 1890’s snake oil salesman’s kit. Are you lacking vigor, young man? Then step right up!

After the oysters, the chowder, and the kombucha bacteria, I was still hungry. I ducked into the Station House Café and splurged on an order of fries and a cocktail. Around me were plenty of families with young children taking lunch. I marveled as the wait-staff managed the cacophony and chaos with friendly attentiveness. The Station House recently celebrated its 45th year in business and here’s to many more. It’s an institution.

The rain subsided in the afternoon and I walked down Main Street to Point Reyes Books, found the perfect book for a rainy day and headed for the recently rebranded and upgraded Olema House, whose location at the corner of Highway 1 and the Sir Francis Drake Boulevard makes the hotel the living gateway into Pt. Reyes National Seashore, with all its trails and hiking opportunities. There’s lots going on out here in coming weeks as spring gets rolling. The 10th annual Point Reyes Birding & Nature Festival takes flight on April 27, on the lawn adjacent to Cowgirl Creamery. Festivalgoers can meet a local owl and a local hawk. The bird event also features all sorts of family-friendly activities—coloring, face painting, and a youth bird walk. The Point Reyes Station Library is loaning bird backpacks to attendees that include binoculars, a bird diagram-book, and a local bird chart. Lucky kids. Then in June, the Pt. Reyes Farmer’s Market will be up and running in and around Toby’s Feed Barn on Saturdays through the summer. It’s said to be the first organic farmers’ market in the greater Bay Area—and was visited by Prince Charles and Lady Camilla back in 2005.

The Junket

I arrived at Olema House for a press junket and was warmly welcomed by host Jan Vanderley at the front desk. He handed me a hot towel, which was welcome relief after all that cold wind and rain. He gave me a tour of the impeccable hotel, which features two dozen rooms, all with a unique theme, and all designed to denote a sense of luxury amid the rugged Point Reyes wilderness. I was in Room 16. The theme there was oyster shells and redwood accents to go along with a page of Kerouac’s On the Road hanging in the bathroom. I unslung my pack and settled in.

The air smelled heavily of cedar, here, a product of both the wood rails and daily fire in the lounge’s stone fireplace. As spring becomes summer, weddings and receptions come through here at a steady clip—2019’s pretty much all booked up—and even during the rainy season the hotel hosts a few corporate events every month.

The rain gave way as I looked out the window and then checked out Room 16’s third-floor balcony. I lit a fire (Olema House provides two Duraflame logs for visitors) and wrote for a few hours before dinner.

Due West is ext door to the hotel and I spent a while there sipping a martini and snacking on roasted almonds while listening to diners’ conversations. I ordered a tomato bisque paired with a light Chardonnay. The bisque was delicious and delicately sweetened with an undercurrent of carrot. I cursed myself for eating all those fries earlier in the day. I could have had a chocolate torte for dessert. Instead I settled into one of the softest beds I’ve ever slept on and broke open Ursula K. Le Guin’s Always Coming Home.

In coming months, Olema House and Due West will expand their culinary offerings with a new spring menu, and a newly renovated deli on the premises—Due West Market—that offer guests picnic baskets full of cheese, bread, wine, and other North Bay delicacies.

No Rush to Go Home

I awoke long before the alarm went off and stayed in bed through the morning and listened to the birds and occasional car driving by on Highway 1. Even out here, civilization makes itself known.

The complimentary breakfast in the lobby featured smoked salmon, sliced tomatoes, and cucumber. It reminded me of European hotel breakfasts, the effect enhanced by sitting near a young German couple. Outside, the fog was lifting. Near the rushing Bear Creek, a little girl played with her dog—the hotel Olema House can also provide bedding, food, and other amenities for guests’ four-legged friends, within reason. Leave the pet emu at home.

I lingered right until checkout time and then set out for the Great Beach, which spans 11 miles along Point Reyes’ western edge. Some sand between my toes would be the perfect way to end the trip . . .

But the road was flooded. I didn’t walk on sand, but the ride home was a delight. Black Mountain, the local massif and spirit guide, glowed emerald green, and guided me back to Petaluma. I might have even seen the face of God.

Tom Gogola went along for part of the ride.

Hero & Zero

Hero

The descendants of Camillo Ynitia (the last chief of the Southern Marin Coast Miwok), are working to keep the tribe’s memory alive, as distinct tribes of indigenous people are blurred into generic tribal groupings. Let’s help them honor their ancestors, who lived on this land for thousands of years, with a striking bronze sculpture created by celebrated Bay Area sculptor Will Pettee. Fundraising efforts are underway to produce a highly-detailed maquette (a small model) statue of a Miwok family, which will be used to promote the creation of the life-size bronze monument. Be a hero and donate at gofundme.com. Search for Coast Miwok monument.

Zero

A duo of brainless bandits took a right turn into the Panda Express drive-thru and found a shortcut to the slammer. It all began when San Francisco police phoned the Marin County Sheriff’s Office to report a tracking device from a stolen U-Haul was pinging near the Target in Marin City last Wednesday morning. Deputies discovered the unoccupied van backed into a space in front of the store. To prevent the suspects from escaping in the vehicle, the deputies placed spike strips in front of its tires.

While keeping the van under surveillance, they contacted Target and learned that security was watching two men in the store who were acting suspiciously. About an hour later, the pair skedaddled from the store, hopped in the van and drove away. So much for the spike strips. Deputies pursued them across the shopping center parking lot to the Panda Express drive-thru, and then observed the Mensa members drive over a berm and into a fence. After a short foot chase, both subjects were arrested. Stolen merchandise from Target was later found in the van.

Justin Wade Keller, 24, of San Francisco, and Brandon Anthony Ramirez, 24, of Concord, were booked into Marin County jail on charges of conspiracy, vehicle theft, shoplifting, possession of stolen property, resisting a public officer and more bad acts.

email: ni***************@***oo.com

Hero & Zero

Hero
The descendants of Camillo Ynitia (the last chief of the Southern Marin Coast Miwok), are working to keep the tribe’s memory alive, as distinct tribes of indigenous people are blurred into generic tribal groupings. Let’s help them honor their ancestors, who lived on this land for thousands of years, with a striking bronze sculpture created by celebrated Bay Area sculptor Will Pettee. Fundraising efforts are underway to produce a highly-detailed maquette (a small model) statue of a Miwok family, which will be used to promote the creation of the life-size bronze monument. Be a hero and donate at gofundme.com. Search for Coast Miwok monument.
Zero
A duo of brainless bandits took a right turn into the Panda Express drive-thru and found a shortcut to the slammer. It all began when San Francisco police phoned the Marin County Sheriff’s Office to report a tracking device from a stolen U-Haul was pinging near the Target in Marin City last Wednesday morning. Deputies discovered the unoccupied van backed into a space in front of the store. To prevent the suspects from escaping in the vehicle, the deputies placed spike strips in front of its tires.
While keeping the van under surveillance, they contacted Target and learned that security was watching two men in the store who were acting suspiciously. About an hour later, the pair skedaddled from the store, hopped in the van and drove away. So much for the spike strips. Deputies pursued them across the shopping center parking lot to the Panda Express drive-thru, and then observed the Mensa members drive over a berm and into a fence. After a short foot chase, both subjects were arrested. Stolen merchandise from Target was later found in the van.
Justin Wade Keller, 24, of San Francisco, and Brandon Anthony Ramirez, 24, of Concord, were booked into Marin County jail on charges of conspiracy, vehicle theft, shoplifting, possession of stolen property, resisting a public officer and more bad acts.
email: ni***************@***oo.com

Letters

California Dreamin’

What a fantastic idea (“Tow Hold,” March 20)! Now I can finally realize my dream of living in the most affluent neighborhoods of California. I’ll just ditch my house, buy a beat up RV and park in Beverly Hills, Atherton, Kentfield and Pacific Heights. Wait, I have an even better idea! Why don’t we establish free parking zones around the residences of our elected officials including Mr Chiu. Why we could even park outside of Gov. Newsom’s new gated (or should I say walled) home in Fair Oaks. Let’s hope AB 516 sails through our thoughtful legislative process.

Mike S., Marin County

Di Fi

Responding to your article ”Di Hard” (March 5), our senator’s treatment of the young petitioners for the Green New Deal is certainly not what I would want from her.

This reminds me of a letter I sent to her four years ago citing my difficulty in reaching her by phone and the lack of response to my letters. I ended it with a request for a response to the situation. No response was ever received.

Meredith Grey, Mill Valley

All Aboard

We’d love our city council to allow for a widened street corner at our Depot Bookstore & Cafe and welcome our friendliest restauranteur, Paul Lazzareschi of Vasco, to run it. Then Mill Valley will have a winner: an improved historic train station where everyone meets.

Dart Cherk, Mill Valley

About the Cover Artist

Artist and educator Sirima Sataman works in traditional printmaking and sculpture from her home in Bolinas and her studio and shop Ink.Paper.Plate in Point Reyes Station. Her art often depicts vintage cultural artifacts and sprawling landscapes that question what we embrace and what we leave behind as we progress into a digital society. We love Sirima!

Drop in the Bucket

0

“It’s a drop in the bucket,” Marin County Supervisor Dennis Rodoni says. The 4th District representative made the rounds in West Marin over the weekend and talked about news of a new $3 million Federal Emergency Management Agency grant that’s being made available to homeowners who live in flood-prone zones in the county’s unincorporated parts.

It’s a drop, sure, but it’s a welcome one to county officials trying to assist flood-prone homeowners through the Local Hazard Mitigation Plan.

And yikes—it’s still raining and flooding this week as the county is now in the process of reviewing dozens of applications seeking a piece of the grant, most of them from the coastal towns of Marshall (15 applications) and Stinson Beach (17 applications). The rub is that not all of the applicants are in a FEMA flood zone area or in a future sea-level-rise area identified by the county in a pair of vulnerability assessments it produced in 2017. They won’t qualify, even if they’re at risk, too.

One vulnerability study determined that future sea level rises in Marin County could, under one scenario, spike by ten inches. Add in a 100-year storm surge and it’s estimated that 8,000 acres of land would flood and 200,000 residents would be displaced or otherwise be impacted. Three ferry landings, five marinas and numerous boat launches would be under threat, commuting employees could be stranded and some 4,500 homes would be flooded.

The current FEMA grant to raise houses to a safe level would be spread across an estimated maximum of 16 homes. A bucket’s drop indeed—but the county says there’s more on the way.

This latest grant opportunity comes as Marin County weather-related events this winter—mudslides in Sausalito, levee breaches in Novato, houses poised to hit the beach in West Marin—are underscoring a regional push to deal with climate-change impacts on storm seasons and anticipated sea level rises. Nobody’s denying climate change in these parts and if they are, they’re drowning under a sea of observable realities.

The buzzword du jour from all quarters these days is resiliency—but can the county keep pace with its visions of resiliency, given the looming sea-level-rise peril?

The deadline for the West Marin FEMA grant was March 22 and the Marin County planning office tells the Pacific Sun this week that they’ve received 39 applications for the $3 million grant to raise houses along the Marin coast. The maximum grant to any household is capped at $243,337, and the homeowner is required to be able to contribute 25 percent of the cost of elevating their structure. The county currently offers no funding boost of its own to assist homeowners of lesser means who are at risk of flooding, but says it’s open to the idea.

The funds are part of a FEMA program designed to build resiliency in parts of the region at risk of flood and fire.

The grant, says Marin County Planning Manager Jack Liebster, came about as a result of the state Disaster Declaration that attended the 2017 Sonoma and Napa county wildfires. The opportunity sprang from the ashes of fire disaster, but localities have the flexibility to deploy the funds to meet local resiliency shortfalls as they see fit. And while it’s true that Marin County’s been described as a “sleeper county” to the extent that it’s overdue for a big wildfire—concerns about flooding and sea level rise are a graver and more real-time threat that’s already affecting the county.

The latest grant is pegged to unincorporated West Marin and is for homeowners in the special flood hazard zone. It’s aimed at helping them get their houses raised above the so-called 100-year-storm line. While it does seem that 100-year storms are occurring every winter, the metric actually refers to the 1 percent statistical probability that a killer storm will hit in any given year. Meteorologists may need to upgrade the metric as storms quicken and intensify.

Marin County homeowners in high-flood-risk areas are subject to a county code that requires homes to be built at least a foot about the 100-year-storm high-water mark. To counteract future predicted sea level rises, the county also encourages anyone near the shoreline to build or raise their home two feet above the 100-year mark mandated by county code. Homeowners in those areas are required to carry pricey flood insurance.

Marin County has gotten two FEMA resiliency grants recently; the other is pegged at flood-prone properties in the eastern part of the county.

As Liebster explains, federal funding is provided under the authority of the Stafford Act through FEMA and the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (CAL OES). The state agency is responsible for identifying program priorities and reviewing sub-applications. They forward recommendations for funding to FEMA. The federal agency has the final say over eligibility.

Meanwhile, in Novato

As the song goes—it kept on raining, and the levee broke. On Valentine’s Day, a sloppy and windy pineapple express roared through the region and breached one of two levees that hold back the engorged Novato Creek. The breach closed State Route 37 between Highway 101 and Atherton Avenue—aka, the Narrows—for several days, snarled traffic and frayed nerves of commuters up and down the North Bay.

The levee breach was visually startling, but not surprising. Route 37 was similarly flooded in the drought-busting winter of 2017. This year, stormwater broke through the creek embankment and levee on the section of land owned by SMART, according to city documents.

Novato has been subject to big floods on a fairly regular basis, going back decades. Still, voters there turned back a 2016 local ballot measure that would have funded flood-remediation efforts through a new tax.

A year later, the city sent a letter to numerous residents who live on the downtown floodplain, informing them that while they weren’t officially in the special flood-hazard zone, they were at great risk of flooding. Novato has more than 5,000 acres designated as Special Flood Hazard Areas (SHFA), and the city notes on its website that a half dozen storms between 1980 and 1998 caused flooding and damaged buildings. “However,” the city notes, “your home need not be located in the SFHA to sustain flood damage.” City officials there urge residents to keep those drainage courses and storm drains free of debris.

The levee breach appears to be an entirely predictable event. In 2016, Novato applied for a FEMA grant to study the levee system with an eye toward improving it. The grant request was denied. In April 2018, Marin County issued a request for proposals to study the Novato levee system. The objective of the project is to “evaluate the geotechnical condition of the existing levees, and determine the feasibility and costs of modifications to address both levee stability and potential improvements that could achieve improved flood protection for FEMA accreditation.”

According to state records online, the 900,000 contract will be split between state and county money: The county committed $400,000 to the study in 2017; the state, under the 2006 Local Levee Assistance Program pledged an additional $500,000 in June 2018. (Elsewhere in Marin County, Larkspur’s levees are currently being studied via a $350,000 contract.)

The proposed study was to be completed by 2020; the implementation date for the proposed Novato levee study was set for this winter.

Just in time for the levee to over-top and wash out State Route 37.

Is This the End?

There’s a dirt road in Bolinas that boasts a killer view of the Duxbury Reef and San Francisco. It’s a quiet block most of the time, barring the occasional obnoxious Airbnb party and the chattering quail that are all over the place up on the Big Mesa. This weekend there’s a Tsunami preparedness drill out here but if the FEMA maps are any indication, Bolinas is pretty well protected from Tsunami impacts through its Big Mesa and Little Mesa (downtown’s a different story). But if a Tsunami hits out here, Stinson Beach is doomed. Forget it. No more Parkside Bread, no more Red Rocks nude beach.

At the end of the Bolinas road, besides the great view, there’s a concrete retaining wall that was installed some years ago to prevent the road from further eroding into the ocean. The talk around town says it cost the resident who built it some $5 million.

It does not appear to be money well spent, as the rains this winter have completely undermined the surrounding area; the wall has itself slipped some twenty feet down the cliff. A nearby home isn’t going to make it through another winter. It’s been condemned by the county.

I live near the cliff and before it collapsed, the retaining wall was my go-to spot for a cup of coffee and the morning meditation. I’ve always had this sweet meditative spot contemplating the sea as it crashes into rocks. Last summer, I headed out there one afternoon and a woman was perched on the retaining wall, reading Hermann Hesse and drinking her coffee. Maybe it was matte. Lately, locals have been coming to check out the erosion, and I go out there every morning to check the status of the house as the cliff inches closer and closer to the back deck. I miss the coffee spot but there are bigger problems in the world.

There’s a line from the Hesse bildungsroman, Beneath the Wheel, that I’ve occasionally meditated on too, and that seems wholly appropriate for Marin County as it chases the money and charts a sea-rise course in the era of resiliency and wild levee breaches.

His small fragile ship had barely escaped a disaster; now it enters a region of new storms and uncharted depths through which even the best led cannot find a guide. He must find his own way and be his own saviour.

Resiliency!

The Demerit-ocracy

0

By Felicia Mello/CALmatters

When state legislators grilled University of California staff at a hearing last week about the agency’s response to the recent college admission scandal, Assemblyman Kevin McCarty asked the question that’s been reverberating since the story broke.

“How do we reassure the public that the system is not totally rigged?”

It’s a dilemma for lawmakers who feel pressure to respond to a nationwide cheating scheme that cuts at the heart of higher education’s legitimacy. Among the dozens of people charged by federal law enforcement with using fake test scores and athletic profiles to secure admission for wealthy students at elite colleges, one was a UCLA soccer coach and another the parent of a UC alumnus. The scandal stung all the more given the massive demand among Californians for a UC degree. Three Marin County parents were caught up in the scandal.

Though the March 22 hearing generated strong talk of crackdowns and expulsions, there are limits to what state government can and can’t do to prevent future scandals. State officials have little ability to influence the private schools at the center of the investigation, and even within California’s public university system, key decisions about admission are made within the ivory tower, by UC faculty and staff.

But legislators do have significant control over UC’s purse strings and the governor and lieutenant governor sit on the UC Board of Regents. Here are three takeaways from the state’s response so far.

UC policy allows campuses to admit up to 6 percent of each entering class as “admissions by exception,” meaning they don’t meet usual standards but have a special talent such as athletics or performing arts.

Those under-the-radar admissions are the kind the FBI alleges parents exploited at UC and elite private schools, by bribing coaches to bring on their children as walk-on players.

They can also be used to increase geographic and cultural diversity, Provost Michael Brown told legislators in late March, by admitting students who were homeschooled or attended high schools in rural areas that don’t offer the courses that UC usually requires.

Brown said actual admissions by exception usually amount to 2 percent or less of each class—campuses don’t use their entire quota because demand for regular slots is so high. Including transfer students, the university received nearly 218,000 undergraduate applications for the 2019-to-2020 school year.

UC officials say they don’t set aside any admissions slots for donors or legacy students—those whose parents attended the university—and audits a random sampling of applications each year to ensure the information submitted is accurate.

Regardless, admissions by exception will likely be a focus of UC’s internal investigation into the extent of the fraud. “We are going to scrub this and see what we can do to improve our processes and . . . make it very difficult for anyone to take advantage of our system,” said the university’s chief audit officer, Alex Bustamante.

More than 1,000 colleges and universities nationwide have stopped requiring applicants to submit SAT or ACT test scores, according to the nonprofit FairTest—including, last year, the prestigious University of Chicago.

The University of California, so far, hasn’t joined their ranks. But the revelation that wealthy families could so brazenly game the tests has lent urgency to an ongoing discussion within the university about their future use.

At the request of UC President Janet Napolitano, a faculty task force has for the last several months been studying whether standardized tests accurately predict how well a student will succeed at the university. Critics of the SAT and ACT have long argued that they perpetuate racial disparities and favor applicants whose families can afford expensive test prep courses.

“I think the scandal has helped people understand how these tests have become synonymous with privilege,” says UC regent Eloy Ortiz Oakley, a longtime critic of the SAT who also serves as chancellor of the California Community Colleges. “What I’m hearing from my colleagues is outrage and concern and a heightened interest in getting back the recommendation from the Academic Senate.”

The College Board defends the SAT’s integrity, saying it relies on schools to provide fair testing environments, but has also taken measures to increase security in recent years.

“No single admissions criteria is perfect, but objective measures like college entrance exams protect hardworking, honest students by making fraud harder to pull off and easier to detect,” Zachary Goldberg, a spokesperson for the board, said in an email.

About 60 percent of freshman applicants to UC’s fall 2019 class submitted SAT scores, 20 percent sent ACT scores, and the rest took both exams. Cal State requires the test for applicants whose high school GPAs are lower than 3.0, or who want to attend a campus or program with high demand.

UC campuses vary in how much they emphasize standardized tests, said Eddie Comeaux, chair of the university’s Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools, the panel that oversees admissions. At some, grades and test results together count for more than 90 percent of an applicant’s score, he said, while others take a more holistic approach.

One option UC could pursue: relying more on the Smarter Balanced tests the state already requires all students to take in 11th grade. Designed to align with school curriculum, Smarter Balanced exams do about as well as the SAT at predicting whether a student will get good grades in their first year at UC or Cal State and return for a second year, according to a forthcoming UC Davis study.

However, the study found both tests were less effective at predicting outcomes for low-income students, said lead author Michal Kurlaender. Students outside California wouldn’t necessarily have access to the Smarter Balanced exams. And in-school state assessment tests, while free and convenient for students to take, have faced cheating scandals of their own.

Expect athletics to come under more scrutiny.

UC officials say any candidates recommended by athletic coaches go through an independent review before they’re admitted.

“For all the processes I know about, no single individual is able to pull the trigger on a decision,” Brown said Tuesday.

But the checks and balances seem to have failed in the case of Jorge Salcedo, a UCLA soccer coach indicted on suspicion of taking $200,000 in bribes to accept two recruits who had never played the sport competitively. UCLA placed Salcedo on leave last week.

When asked whether admissions officers actually contact a student’s high school to verify athletic accomplishments, director of admissions Han Mi Yoon-Wu acknowledged that in deciding on a candidate, they often rely on coaches’ expertise.

That should change, said Comeaux, a former professional baseball player who researches athletics in higher education.

“My suggestion would be to make sure you have more faculty oversight,” he says, adding that the admissions board will take up the issue at its April meeting. He pointed to UC Berkeley, which tightened admissions standards for athletes in recent years in response to low graduation rates among its football players, as a possible model.

That’s one reform legislators might also urge UC to adopt. “We need to make sure the person who got on the swim team knows how to swim,” says McCarty.

This story and other higher education coverage are supported by the College Futures Foundation. CALmatters.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California policies and politics.

 

SCHOOLHOUSE ROCKS

Marin State Assemblyman Marc Levine’s got a pretty good idea going this week. He introduced AB 1648 on Tuesday in an effort to streamline the state-mandated environmental review for affordable housing that’s build on local school district surplus properties.

The idea, of course, is to bring teachers and, perhaps, parents closer to the schools they work at or send their kids to. The bill would give authority school districts to provide housing preference for teachers, who often cannot afford to live where they work in pricey Marin. Levine’s bill takes aim at the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) by requiring approvals of affordable housing projects on school district owned properties within seven months of the filing of a certified record of the CEQA proceedings with a court. That’s a long way of saying that his bill would limit or eliminate costly lawsuits from neighbors who may disapprove of the affordable housing plan.

In a statement, Levine notes that the same CEQA rule applies to the building of sports stadiums and called on lawmakers to expedite the process for affordable housing too. Marin Superintendent of Schools Mary Jane Burke’s in favor of the local pols’ latest legislative push as she notes that having affordable-housing options for teachers and staff “will enable our schools to attract and retain a quality workforce,” she says. ”Our students deserve the very best educational opportunities and retaining qualified staff is paramount to making this happen.”

PREMIUM PLAN

Napa State Senator Bill Dodd’s got a pretty good idea, too, that’s now making its way through Sacramento’s committee process. SB 290 would, for the first time, allow the State of California to take out an insurance policy on itself in the (pretty likely) event of future wildfires or other disasters. “Why doesn’t the state have disaster insurance to reduce its financial exposure,” he asks, non-rhetorically.

Dodd’s bill is co-sponsored by Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara and state Treasurer Fiona Ma. The bill authorizes their agencies, and the governor’s office, to “enter into an insurance policy that pays out when California has unexpected disaster costs.” It would basically work like a home insurance policy.

Dodd notes in a statement that this is how they do it in Oregon, not to mention at the World Bank. They’ve both used insurance policies to protect taxpayers from financial exposure after a disaster, though it’s unclear when Oregon has faced a big disaster of any kind, besides those freakish neo-Nazis of Portland. OK, that time Mt. St. Helena blew up, that was pretty bad.

—Tom Gogola

Flashback

40 Years Ago

THIS WEEK

Three men from Mill Valley can’t find any sane reason for marijuana being illegal and they are doing their best to help repeal the 1937 state law against marijuana and hashish. The three are Stephen Samuels, Richard Moon and Paul Ehrlich. They’re spearheading the northern California campaign to circulate enough petitions to qualify for the June 1980 ballot.

Just think of what the tax-poor cities and the county of Marin could do with the cannabis sales tax, folks. Our worries would be over.

But what bothers the proponents of the initiative even more is that it costs $600 million tax dollars a year to enforce outdated marijuana laws. “It’s a $48 billion industry gone underground, untaxed,” said Samuels this week as he distributed quantities of petitions around the county.

—Joanne Williams, March 23–29, 1979

50 Years Ago

THIS WEEK

The county’s intrepid dope squad came up with two intriguing, if not particularly weighty, raids. Nailed were a cleaning place in Larkspur where LSD was allegedly being dispensed, and a birthday party in San Rafael where the cook had purportedly improved on Alice B. Toklas and her marijuana brownies by putting grass in the birthday cake. However, out in West Marin the raiders drew a complete blank. A ten-man swoop on a ranch house provided not so much as a single marijuana seed.

—Newsgram, March 23, 1969

Shine On

0

At a time when occupational safety regulations are being loosened and funding for the agencies responsible for their enforcement being reduced, it’s good to be reminded how those safeguards came to be and what life was like for American workers before then.

The Ross Valley Players’ production of Melanie Marnich’s These Shining Lives does just that.

Part domestic drama, part workplace tragedy, the play is based on the true story of the women who worked for the Radium Dial Company of Ottawa, Illinois, in the late 1920s through the early ’30s. It focuses on Catherine Donahue (Jessica Dahlgren), a happily married mother of two who joins the workforce to help support her family. Her husband Tom (Frankie Stornaiuolo) isn’t thrilled by the thought of a working wife.

Catherine joins a work crew whose task is to paint the numbers and hands on watches and clocks with luminescent radium. The process is simple: lick the brush and bring it to a point, dip the brush in the radium, apply to watch elements, repeat.

It’s not long before Catherine starts to feel ill, but the company doctor merely prescribes aspirin. In a company town, she finds it tough to get anyone to listen to her and her co-workers as their ailments get worse. It’ll take a trip to Chicago to find a doctor and eventually a lawyer who will listen, and it will be years before they are really heard. Their time is severely limited.

Marnich has latched onto a fascinating story and done a pretty good job of telling it. The workplace scenes work better than those at the homestead, where the dialogue frequently lapses into the trite—“How did I ever find you?” “Just lucky, I guess.”

Director Mary Ann Rodgers casts it well, with Dahlgren and Stornaiuolo overcoming weak dialogue to create compelling characters. Jazmine Pierce, Sarah Williams and Carly Van Liere play her co-workers, and each do a fine job with their semi-stock roles (the funny one, the harsh one, etc.)

The time-related set design by co-star Malcolm B. Rodgers (he essays several roles) and the scenic artistry by Kristy Arroyo complement the subject matter as does the sound design by Billie Cox.

Ross Valley Players’ These Shining Lives is a well-mounted production that serves both as a reminder of how things once were and a warning that, without diligence, they can be again.

‘These Shining Lives’ runs Thursday–Sunday through March 31 at the Barn Theatre in the Marin Art and Garden Center, 30 Sir Francis Drake Blvd., Ross. Times vary. $12–$27. 415.883.4498. rossvalleyplayers.com.

Letters

Unionize!

The UFCW is one of the largest private sector Unions in the whole United States (“Look for the Union . . . Edible,” March 20). We are organizing in all states where cannabis is [legalized]. We must educate the cannabis owners and investors that workers do have rights to organize and demand better working conditions, to respect workers rights to say or complain without the threat of being discharged or terminated for organizing. . . . This cannabis industry has been asked to do what other employer’s have been doing in the state of California—respect workers rights to join a union of free choice. UFCW local 5 has contracts with dispensaries. We had the first members in Oakland and Berkeley in 2012. We are now also looking for employers who wish to sign a labor peace agreement with UFCW Local 5.

Juan Cervantes

UFCW Local 5

Rediscovering San Anselmo

Really enjoyed this article (“San Anselmo’s Fire,” March 6). San Anselmo is in my own backyard but it opened my eyes further. I think I’ll pop in to Routes Gallery, I drive by every day and have never been in! Thank you for a fun informative article with delicious food descriptions.

M. Kathryn Thompson

Via Pacificsun.com

Hero & Zero

A scammer ensnared a Marinite in his scheme and added $2,500 to his coffer. Before you say you wouldn’t fall for it, keep in mind these hustlers talk a good game and the elderly in our community are particularly vulnerable.

This swindle began with a person we’ll call Eleanor receiving a phone call from “Sam Fox with the Social Security Administration.” He gave his badge number, asked questions to establish Eleanor’s identity and then transferred her to the fraud division.

A new person weaved a story about the FBI seizing 22 pounds of cocaine from a car registered in Eleanor’s name. In addition, several bank accounts in the same name were being used for money laundering.

The fraudster requested five Google Play gift cards totaling $2,500 to verify the victim’s real bank accounts, with the promise to reimburse the money by the end of the day. Growing suspicious, she informed the caller she didn’t believe him.

Ever the pro at keeping his prey engaged, he texted a letter from Social Security, which detailed criminal charges for drug trafficking and money laundering. Eleanor must stay on the phone and comply with the demands, or risk arrest and jail.

She purchased the gift cards and provided her checking info. Now he asked for $3,000 to verify her savings account. Wary, she googled Sam Fox and his badge number. The scam popped up.

Still fearful of arrest, Eleanor stayed on the line, but she drove to the Marin County sheriff’s office. They instructed her to hang up. Unbelievably, the thief continued to call and even sent a text message indicating a warrant for her arrest had been issued.

Though the grifters performed their parts well, warning signs existed:

The use of gift cards.

Demand to stay on the phone.

The threat of arrest.

If in doubt, hang up and call the police. For those of us with elderly relatives, talk to them about these scams perpetrated by slick callers.

Got a Hero or a Zero? Please send submissions to ni***************@***oo.com. Toss roses, hurl stones with more Heroes and Zeroes at pacificsun.com.

Trunk Sale

Aside from some gross racial caricaturing the original Dumbo (1941) is an unusually hand-made cartoon. Here in 64 minutes is not just the elephant child’s tragedy at being separated from its mother, but the sweat and stink of a circus, and a squad of clowns who are dangerous and who really know their business. In the magnificent “Pink Elephants...

Western Swing

If there is a place that better blends agricultural heritage with a literate, urbane sensibility than Point Reyes Station and environs, then I haven’t found it. First stop? Philip K. Dick’s former house, a kind of pilgrimage for me, as Dick’s one of my favorite writers. The science-fiction legend famously lived in town for a few years in the late...

Hero & Zero

Hero The descendants of Camillo Ynitia (the last chief of the Southern Marin Coast Miwok), are working to keep the tribe’s memory alive, as distinct tribes of indigenous people are blurred into generic tribal groupings. Let’s help them honor their ancestors, who lived on this land for thousands of years, with a striking bronze sculpture created by celebrated Bay Area...

Hero & Zero

Hero The descendants of Camillo Ynitia (the last chief of the Southern Marin Coast Miwok), are working to keep the tribe’s memory alive, as distinct tribes of indigenous people are blurred into generic tribal groupings. Let’s help them honor their ancestors, who lived on this land for thousands of years, with a striking bronze sculpture created by celebrated Bay Area...

Letters

California Dreamin’ What a fantastic idea (“Tow Hold,” March 20)! Now I can finally realize my dream of living in the most affluent neighborhoods of California. I’ll just ditch my house, buy a beat up RV and park in Beverly Hills, Atherton, Kentfield and Pacific Heights. Wait, I have an even better idea! Why don’t we establish free parking zones...

Drop in the Bucket

“It’s a drop in the bucket,” Marin County Supervisor Dennis Rodoni says. The 4th District representative made the rounds in West Marin over the weekend and talked about news of a new $3 million Federal Emergency Management Agency grant that’s being made available to homeowners who live in flood-prone zones in the county’s unincorporated parts. It’s a drop, sure, but...

The Demerit-ocracy

By Felicia Mello/CALmatters When state legislators grilled University of California staff at a hearing last week about the agency’s response to the recent college admission scandal, Assemblyman Kevin McCarty asked the question that’s been reverberating since the story broke. “How do we reassure the public that the system is not totally rigged?” It’s a dilemma for lawmakers who feel pressure to respond...

Shine On

At a time when occupational safety regulations are being loosened and funding for the agencies responsible for their enforcement being reduced, it’s good to be reminded how those safeguards came to be and what life was like for American workers before then. The Ross Valley Players’ production of Melanie Marnich’s These Shining Lives does just that. Part domestic drama, part workplace...

Letters

Unionize! The UFCW is one of the largest private sector Unions in the whole United States (“Look for the Union . . . Edible,” March 20). We are organizing in all states where cannabis is . We must educate the cannabis owners and investors that workers do have rights to organize and demand better working conditions, to respect workers rights...

Hero & Zero

A scammer ensnared a Marinite in his scheme and added $2,500 to his coffer. Before you say you wouldn’t fall for it, keep in mind these hustlers talk a good game and the elderly in our community are particularly vulnerable. This swindle began with a person we’ll call Eleanor receiving a phone call from “Sam Fox with the Social Security...
3,002FansLike
3,850FollowersFollow